Hakirah: The Flatbush Journal of Jewish Law and Thought (Volume 32)

This volume of Ḥakirah emerges amidst a period of uncertainty, unease, and change, both in the world in general and in the Jewish world in particular. The articles in this issue deal with the challenges of responding to changing times and circumstances, both historically and in our own era.
Our Jewish Thought section deals with Israel’s response to change and to modernity in general. Our opening article, “Maimonides on the Messianic Era: The Grand Finale of Olam Ke-Minhago Noheg,”shows that Rambam’s core messianic teaching is an outgrowth of his entire religious perspective “which eschews divine intervention and promotes human initiative.” The second article, “For the Love of Humanity: The Religious Humanism of Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch,” looks closely at Hirsch’s universalist vision and seeks to use it as a guide for dealing with modernity. In “The Search for the Elusive Center: Norman Lamm and American Orthodoxy,”the authorexplains that Rabbi Lamm’s goal in renaming Modern Orthodoxy as Centrist Orthodoxy was to clarify the movement’s ideology and enhance its attractiveness. He contends, however, that “the failure of the attempted rebranding illustrates the internal contradictions of an Orthodox Judaism open to the intellectual and social currents of the wider world” and then points out new challenges that still need to be faced.
A collection of the private correspondence of Rav Joseph B. Soloveitchik, zẓ”l, opens a window into the Rav’s views on a host of issues. Of special interest are letters dealing with his relationship to the State of Israel. While the Rav never ceased his great support for the State of Israel—one letter confirms his support for Mizrachi—other letters show he also recognized secular Zionism’s anti-religious trends and sought to oppose them. Ultimately, he refuses to vie for the chief rabbinate, explaining that the time dedicated to politics would not enable him to learn and teach Torah properly, and concluding, “I am a melamed.”In yet another letter, “A Letter from Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik to Aaron Zeitlin,”the Rav speaks of his belief—in direct opposition to that of Israel’s leaders—that the new State of Israel must be guided by the philosophy that emerges from halakhah and that, indeed, the entire world needs to be guided by it. Rambam’s messianic view lies at the heart of the Rav’s vision of a New World Order emerging from the sources of halakhah.
In our Jewish Law section, in “Tax Ethics in Rashba’s Responsa to Saragossa,”we see the universalist potential of halakhah, as the insights of one of our greatest rishonim are echoed much later by the legendary justice, Judge Learned Hand. Another article in this section, “Criminal Proceedings Against a Jew in a Non-Jewish Court for Get Refusal: The Effect on the Validity of the Get,” argues that modern government institutions can be used to aid Jewish courts in preventing the state of igun.